Evaluating Split Placement Networks

by Veronica Blatt

Independent recruiters have a lot of choices when it comes to finding recruiting partners to help them make more placements. There are job boards, informal networks, social media networks, and recruitment associations, to name a few. There are also split placement networks. A split placement network is a smart decision for many independent recruiters. But how do you know which one is right for your recruitment business? Here are four major criteria to consider when evaluating a split placement network:

  1. Geographic Reach. What are your current and future geographic needs? Do you source local candidates to fill local positions? Is that a sustainable business model for the next 5-10 years? Do your clients operate globally? Are you interested in global recruitment? If you are a global-minded recruiter, with an international business focus, you’ll want to seek out a split placement network that supports those needs.
  2. Industries, Niches, and Occupations. There are many different ‘flavors’ of split placement networks. Do you recruit in a specific niche? Do you work an entire industry, or only a certain occupation? A good split placement network can help you make more placements in your existing space as well as help you broaden the scope of your recruitment activities.
  3. Ownership. Who owns the split placement network? This is an important question for a couple of reasons. First, if the network is owned by an individual, the profit motive is typically for that individual. In other words, the person who owns the network makes decisions that will maximize his or her personal profits. Second, if you’re joining a split placement network that has a single owner, will you have a ‘voice’ in any decision-making? Do you care? If you have a passion for leadership or a desire to ‘give back’ to your profession, will you have any opportunities to do so?
  4. Policies & Procedures. How are disputes handled? Are there specific rules in place for how split placements are handled? What happens if another member interferes with your client relationship? Even more important, will you be protected if you don’t get paid your portion of a fee?

There are no right or wrong answers to these questions. They are strategic questions, and differ widely for different recruiting firms. Look for a split placement network that is a good fit for your current needs, and can also help you grow your business. Click the button below for a free checklist to help you evaluate split placement networks.

 


3 Key Differences Between NPAworldwide and BountyJobs

by Sarah Freiburger

As the Director of Membership for NPAworldwide, I occasionally am asked by independent recruiters how our network is different and better than BountyJobs. In my opinion, neither one is necessarily better than the other as they are so very different. As an independent recruiter, deciding which to join will depend on how you like to work.

The following is a brief summary of the key differences between NPAworldwide and BountyJobs:

1.    Organization Structure
NPAworldwide is a member-owned and -run network of independently-owned recruiting firms that work together to make split placements. The network began in 1956 and has grown into a network of more than 400 firms located throughout the world.

Owners of NPAworldwide firms set the strategic direction of the network. The network is led by a Board of Directors of owners of member firms and has a selective membership process. At the end of the year, profits are re-invested in the network to continue and improve services to our members.

Membership gives independent recruiters and small firms a way to compete in a global marketplace without sacrificing the unique qualities that distinguish them from larger competitors. Members rely on our split placement network to build relationships that result in more effective and efficient service to clients and candidates in their own market. Those relationships translate into enhanced revenue-generating opportunities and increased financial stability. In the process, members also add value to their businesses through improved speed, reach, and capacity.

BountyJobs is a privately-owned company so I do not know how profits are spent or distributed. In 2011, BountyJobs was impressively ranked No. 389 on Inc. magazine’s annual Inc. 500. The press release announcing this ranking states that “BountyJobs is the preferred contingent search solution for more than one-third of the Fortune 500 . . .”   The organization appears to be a good solution for large employers managing a high volume of open positions resulting in the need for them to manage relationships with many recruiters.

2.    Work Style
Success in NPAworldwide is a result of the relationships built between recruiters. The quickest way to build trust with potential trading partners is to meet face-to-face at one of our conferences. Of course, if that is not possible, recruiters develop relationships through telephone, Skype, and/or email conversations.

In BountyJobs, independent recruiters only work with employers and have limited opportunities to build a relationship with an employer until much later in the hiring process.

3.    Control
In NPAworldwide, recruiters post jobs and candidates in our private, web-based sharing tool called SplitZone.  Recruiters may work on any job, anywhere in the world. We also have a private Job Board where only NPAworldwide recruiters can post their jobs. Members can post their jobs for free on our Job Board and only pay if they place a Job Board candidate in a job. With NPAworldwide, an individual recruiter is in control of how they work with their trading partners as long as they abide by the Bylaws and operating procedures.

BountyJobs is a one-way street. Employers post jobs through BountyJobs. Then after viewing posted jobs, recruiters may contact employers and request that they be given permission to send candidates to the employers. A recruiter cannot speak with an employer unless the employer authorizes the recruiter to send candidates. After the permission is granted, the recruiter is able to view the full contact information of the employer. Wiith BountyJobs, the employer is definitely in control.

Additionally, NPAworldwide recruiters control the type of guarantee they offer employers. With BountyJobs, recruiters have no control. All recruiters are required to provide a 60-day money back guarantee; no exceptions.

In conclusion, which option is better for independent recruiters to join – NPAworldwide or BountyJobs?  It  depends! NPAworldwide is a relationship-based network facilitating split placements among its members. If you prefer to not build relationships with your trading partners, then you should consider BountyJobs.  Or, if you are undecided, you may want to consider joining both and experiencing them each firsthand.

If you do consider joining BountyJobs as an independent recruiter, I suggest you take some time to understand how candidate ownership is addressed. Specifically, who owns the candidate six months after a recruiter submits the candidate to an employer.

As an independent recruiter, which option do you prefer?


Independent Recruiters Can Increase Revenue with Temp and Contracting

by Veronica Blatt

Today’s guest blogger is Judy Collins from TFI Resources, an NPA Alliance Partner. TFI Resources is a multi-state payroll service providing a full range of services to recruiters in the temporary, contract, and permanent placement industry by providing employer of record service, payroll funding, and payroll processing. Many independent recruiters utilize TFI to expand their business to include temporary and contract placements while mid-size and large staffing firms use TFI to serve as employer of record for temporary and contract placements in states where they are not registered or licensed to do business.

Don’t miss out on a consistent recruiting revenue stream.

According to Barb Bruno, staffing trends show an increase in temp and contract placements. The new federal healthcare reform will impact your business. Many employers will prefer to add temporary and contract positions before hiring additional permanent staff. Baby boomers that are retiring will come back for a temporary assignment or a short term project. By adding temp and contract alternatives to an existing business model, independent recruiters can create a full service option for their existing clients. You can give them an option on how you can help them satisfy their staffing needs. With so much competition, it is all about providing the right option.

An average markup rate for a temp or contract position is usually 50% of the pay rate. This can also depend on your niche market. You can choose to have a lower mark up for a large client or a client that will give you multiple assignments. You can also go higher for those hard-to-fill priority positions. Be sure to include a buy-out clause after 90-120 days. When calculating your conversion fee only look at your profit margin, do not include your total billings. The total invoice amounts include what you are spending on payroll, taxes and insurance. If you outsource your back office, also take out your payroll funding and payroll processing fees. Include language in your placement agreements that the conversion fee will be calculated off of profit for the term of the assignment if your client chooses to hire your candidate within one year of the last day worked.

Temp and contract placements can help keep clients happy while increasing an independent recruiter’s bottom line.


Ten Terrific Mobile Recruiting Resources

by Veronica Blatt

I’ve written before about how important it is for independent recruiters to knowledgeable about mobile recruiting technology. If I sound like an alarmist, good! Too many recruitment websites are badly outdated in terms of technology and functionality. Independent recruiters simply cannot afford to fall any further behind in the mobile recruiting game.

Here is a list of ten mobile recruiting resources, in no particular order:

Are you ready for the mobile recruiting revolution? What’s your favorite mobile recruiting resource?

Image(s): FreeDigitalPhotos.net


Make More Split Placements with Better Job Descriptions

by Veronica Blatt

Today’s post is from Russ Bray with Southern Recruiting Solutions in Tampa, Florida. Russ is a two-time member of the NPA Board of Directors, as well as a long-time member of the network. Southern Recruiting Solutions specializes in placing engineering and information technology professionals throughout the U.S.

Have you ever read a job description that never seems to end and that no one could possibly qualify for? Or one that really tells you nothing because it’s all generic jargon? Candidates have too—and either no one replied, or everyone replied. We hear so many complaints about poor response to job postings. Here are a few tips that may help you increase your reply from quality candidates. If you are sharing the job with a member of your split placement network, he or she will thank you as well.

  1. A little sizzle to start – ‘Opportunity to join a software development team building new applications using .NET Framework 4.’ Regardless of the industry or job, provide some detail at the beginning to excite a potential candidate. This will set you apart from the rest of the crowd. It will also help your split placement partner get more excited about conducting a search and targeting the right candidate.
  2. Several bullets that clearly state what this person will be doing. There is no magic number, but I like to keep it brief; 5 or so bullets that don’t ramble on forever.
  3. Several bullets that clearly state what is necessary to qualify for this position. Usually this section is the one that seems to go on and on. Try to focus on the top 5 experiences this person will need to qualify for the job. Is a Masters degree absolutely necessary or will the right experience offset that requirement? Do they have to have experience from another chemical plant or could someone from another manufacturer do the job just as well? Don’t make it hard for your split placement partners and/or candidates to figure out what is needed; they’ll just give up in frustration.

If the job description you are working from is much longer, just list the most important bullets and state that more detail can be provided to qualified candidates. Items like ‘good team player’ and ‘excellent verbal and written communication skills’ are a given and not really necessary. Some sizzle, concise and brief, is usually best. Better job descriptions will help you make more placements, including split placements.

If you are sharing the job with a member of your split placement network, he or she will thank you as well.


Independent Recruiters: Take an Interest in Pinterest

by Veronica Blatt

Lately, it seems everyone is talking about Pinterest. I’ve been thinking for awhile about how I could include one of my favorite pastimes, “pinning”, in a blog and decided today was the day I would give it a shot. Pinterest has experienced the fastest growth in the history of any social media site and sends more referral traffic than YouTube and Google+. I think it’s time I bring you up to speed on how you can use Pinterest in your recruiting firm. Read the rest of this entry »


The World Needs More Independent Recruiters

by Veronica Blatt

business-cardToday’s guest blogger is Martin Snyder, Main Sequence Technology. Founded in 1998, Main Sequence Technology creates talent acquisition technology solutions wherever and however organizations are built. PCRecruiter is the solution of choice for thousands of third party recruitment, corporate, and outsourced staffing teams across economic models and around the world. PCRecruiter provides comprehensive CRM and ATS functionality converged into database, voice, and email interfaces to empower recruiters to do what they do best with accessible, cost effective technology. Main Sequence is proud to serve the NPA organization and our many individual NPA affiliated customers. To learn more, please visit www.pcrecruiter.net.

As a guest blogger, I wanted to bring one of my old saws along. I have posted versions of it elsewhere, so if you have seen it, at least you don’t have to hear me expound (at length) about it over a root beer.

It goes something like this: The World Needs More Independent Recruiters.

More recruiters doing more recruiting could bring some measure of unemployment relief, but importantly, more recruiting may actually increase real economic development. To convince the world of that proposition, the world needs a better understanding of who independent recruiters are, and how they create value.

Easier said than done. Recruiting is deceptively simple to explain, yet complex in the execution, with widely varying performance styles and backgrounds among highly successful recruiters. Even many otherwise savvy business professionals have little understanding of what recruiters actually do.

In January 2012, a blog entry was published on Recruiter.com that generated thousands of tweets and Likes. The post starts with the story of Twenty Heartbeats. In an ancient country, a rich man wants a painting of a beloved horse. He takes the horse to an artist, and pays much gold in advance. The artist looks the horse over, and then goes off to paint. After years go by, the horse is old, and the rich man is angry by the lack of production of the painting. He confronts the artist, who whereupon paints the horse in a few brush strokes (twenty heartbeats of work), and the painting is incredibly brilliant and lifelike in every way. Enraged by this display, the rich man turns his back on the artist, but as he is leaving the artist’s home, the man sees the thousands of studies, scraps, and nearly complete paintings of the horse that the artist made in preparation to be able to create the stellar work in just twenty heartbeats.

The metaphor, of course, directly applies to recruiting; while it looks easy enough to persuade a person to move from one job to another, in the real world, it actually takes years of study, market expertise, and an intangible knack to reliably make it happen. Owners of independent recruiting firms understand that if a person does not have the knack, hard work and training are best invested in others. Recruiters are salespeople. High stakes salespeople.

A house is a pile of sticks, a car a hunk of metal and plastic. A job is identity, security, ambition, and social position. HR people are constantly talking about “fit” and “culture” when they talk about recruiting and staffing. It seems that the act of moving between tribes is a process choreographed around deeper evolutionary and cultural roots to comfort both the newcomer and the tribe that there is a fit; a mutual desire that can be reasonably counted on.

People who wish to learn about and understand cultural phenomena reflecting the knowledge and meanings guiding the life of a cultural group are called ethnographers (from Greek ethnos = folk/people and grapho = to write).

Superior recruiters are often superior ethnographers, able to understand and manipulate the knowledge and meanings that create the culture of organizations – both sources of and targets for candidate talent. Superior recruiters are market makers of Social Capital. Social capital refers to connections within and between social networks, which helps explain why social media has had an explosive impact on the profession. As a sociological concept, the prevalent view is that the greater the stock of social capital, the higher the likelihood of positive economic outcomes for any given group.

To be sure, independent recruiters are capable of creating jobs where no job actually exists according to many models. According to The Establishment Level Behavior of Vacancies and Hiring (NBER Working Paper No. 16265), in most models of search, matching, and hiring in the labor market, employers post vacancies to attract job seekers. Many establishments with zero reported vacancies at month’s end do hire new employees the following month. Establishments reporting zero vacancies at month’s end account for 42% of all hires the following month. Only about half of that gap can be explained with current econometric models, implying that many hires are not mediated through vacancies.

Independent recruiters know exactly how many of these hires are made: an organization was presented with the opportunity to bring on a particular person with a given set of attributes, and a latent or new role was created, formalized, or activated as a response to that presentation.

That presentation is very often the work of a professional recruiter.

Coincident with the rise of social media in recruiting, the subspecialty of Sourcing has become recognized. Recently, the American National Standards Institute (ANSI), for the first time ever, recognized a standard for HR (Cost per Hire), which identified sourcing activities as a distinct component of staffing operations occurring prior to the job application.

Sourcing and Recruiting are often synonyms in practice.

By whatever name and in whatever environment, recruiting is a basic economic activity. Recruiting takes place everywhere that organizations are built. Effective recruiting means understanding cultures and effective management of social capital. Applying recruiting skills more formally in economic development efforts, taking a market-based approach to working with unemployed candidates, and identifying and developing the sales talent inherently required for superior recruiting results are ways to enhance economic results for individuals and organizations. In my opinion, it is undeniable that the world needs more recruiters and greater understanding of what recruiters really do.

For those anticipating purely technological solutions, it may come as a surprise, but in matters of high-impact social situations, computerized browsing does not evade encounters, it merely prepares them under the best auspices. The same implacable laws will be in force as soon as the persons involved are in contact.

In the arena of the implacable rules of moving between tribes, recruiters are looking like irreplaceable players. It’s my old saw that the world needs more of ‘em.

 explore-membership


Are resumes still a valid recruiting resource?

by Veronica Blatt

image of woman preparing for a job interviewThere are beginning to be more conversations about whether resumes (or CVs, in other parts of the world), are still a necessary recruiting resource. It’s not a new argument. After all, certain types of professionals (visual arts, graphic designers, etc.) have always relied on a portfolio of works instead of a traditional resume. And the idea of being ‘paperless’ has been a much-hyped goal for at least 20 years.

But it feels different to me this time. And I think we might, actually, be at the beginning of the decline of the traditional paper resume.

What’s different?

Well, for one thing, this time around, the conversation isn’t just limited to new media or high-tech Silicon Valley candidates. Some companies are starting to experiment with more ‘traditional’ kinds of roles. Employers are realizing more and more, that a candidate’s ability to ‘fit’ the corporate culture is often just as important, if not more so, than their ability to do the job. It’s tough to get a sense of ‘fit’ from a sterile, one-dimensional resume.

For another, it’s no secret that employers are making “social media research” part of their screening process. While it may be true that such efforts are often a tool to reduce the candidate pool, there are some amazingly great things about candidates that are online. In addition to a LinkedIn profile, there are blogs, digital portfolios, slide decks, and content curation sites like Scoop.it and even, perhaps, Pinterest, that can show a more complete picture of the candidate as a person. It’s early days, and most candidates probably aren’t doing these things (or doing them well), but those who are probably have a competitive advantage.

As for independent recruiters, for whom the resume has long been the ‘gold standard’ by which candidates are measured, The Ladders reports that the average recruiter spends just six seconds (!!) per resume during the initial screening process. Six seconds? It’s tough for me to believe that anyone can make an accurate assessment about anything other than cursory keywords in six seconds. That’s the best recruiting resource to assess a candidate’s potential?

Finally, I believe that the staggering proliferation of mobile devices may very likely cause the death of the resume as we know it. Not this year, maybe not in five years, but I think it’s coming. Candidates are using smart phones for everything. They aren’t storing a resume on their phone. It’s not something they can access easily in a mobile environment. There are now recruiting firms and other services offering suggestions on how to make mobile-friendly resumes. Independent recruiters and employers are increasingly mobile, too, with their own smart phones and (to a lesser degree) tablets. How does that six seconds thing work for you when you’re trying to read resumes on your iPhone? Hiring managers and HR professionals are reviewing resumes on mobile devices when they are away from the office, and the traditional format simply does not translate well to the small screen.

I don’t think the revolution is upon us yet. Resumes are a deeply entrenched part of the recruiting process. It will take time before many traditional employers will be ready to let go and embrace a different (still undefined) alternative.

Are resumes still a prime recruiting resource in your recruitment agency? What do you hear from clients?

 image of explore membership button


Recruiting Trends: College Grad Hiring to Increase in 2012

by Dave Nerz

It looks like 2012 grads will have a better chance of employment than their recent predecessors. The National Association of Colleges and Employers (NACE) has released its annual Job Outlook Survey. The survey is likely good news for both grads and recruiting organizations that provide recruiting resources to recent grads. A separate NACE survey shows  specifically that employers plan to increase hiring of college graduates by 9.5% in 2012, while the current survey details desirable skills or qualities sought by those making hiring decisions for recent college graduates.

The ten most desirable abilities that employers seek in new graduate hires are: Read the rest of this entry »


7 Ways to Increase Your Recruiting Firm Valuation

by Veronica Blatt

golden-eggAs the Associate Director of Membership for a global recruiters network, I see split placements being made every day. With each recruiter taking home 47.5% of the client fee, it adds up quickly – and for most of our members, it’s more like “icing on the cake” for the profitability of their business. So, it goes without saying that recruiting can be a very lucrative business, but what happens when you decide you want to retire? How do you ensure that your independent recruiting firm has a resale value that amounts to more than your unpredictable client list?

Add contract work – Active contracts are guaranteed revenue for your business and can be valued and purchased outright. Obviously, this is more tangible than working on a contingent basis.

Expand your client base – If 70% of your business comes from one client and that client decides to move to another recruiting firm, your business will be significantly devalued.

Specialize – Once your specific niche is defined, figure out how to grow it. You want to be the “go-to” firm for executive placements in your specialized niche. Your team should experts  and this knowledge will give them an edge with clients and prospects.

Create business procedures – Create standard business procedures and document them. It is valuable information, especially if they are efficient and help make your firm successful.

Use a unique business name – Avoid naming the firm after yourself, e.g. “Smith Global Services.” Chances are the party interested in purchasing doesn’t have the last name Smith.

Try (as much as possible) to avoid turn-over – If your top producer decides to stick with the firm through the sale, they are a big asset and valuable to the bottom line.

Purchase real estate – It goes without saying, but owning the building or space where your business is operated will significantly increase the sale price. Even if the building is not being purchased, it’s an asset that can be sold seperately.

Disclaimer: I’m not a black, blue, or even green level expert in this area. Most of what I’ve included might already in your exit strategy, but it never hurts to continually re-evaluate based on the current economic and industry conditions. The bottom line is – your business is worth what someone is willing to pay for it.

What are you doing in your global recruiting firm to ensure a high business valuation?

image of explore membership button


Please ensure Javascript is enabled for purposes of website accessibility