Recruiting Resources

What causes turndowns, and what can an agency recruiter do about it?

by Veronica Blatt

agency recruiters participating in salary negotiationsIt’s no secret that top talent is scarce in many (most?) employment sectors today. Candidates are receiving multiple offers, including counteroffers from their current employers, at a level (and ferocity) which we haven’t seen or heard of in quite some time. In turn, this is leading to a significant increase in turndowns. There are multiple factors at play during the offer stage; here are a few that contribute to turndowns. A good agency recruiter can be a crucial piece of the puzzle, helping two sides reach a fair deal. Read the rest of this entry »


Recruitment Agencies Can Save Time with Video Interviews

by Dave Nerz

image of recruiter conducting a video interviewEmployers and recruiters alike are using web-based job video interviews to screen candidates for employment or to make hiring decisions. While this is not new, it seems that many recruitment agencies are not keeping up with this trend. There are many great tools out there that help facilitate these interviews ranging from Skype, a generic video chat tool, to InterviewStream or HireVue products made specifically for employers and recruitment agencies.

As with many new technology trends, the use of these tools was at first most prevalent with the high-tech companies and those with large global hiring needs. Global recruiters and recruitment agency networks were also early adopters of the video interview concept. These tools allow hiring managers to view the video interview and create a short-list for fellow managers to offer feedback. The ability for each manager to see the same questions, presented identically and then responded to by each candidate, is a great leveler of the playing field. For the employer, video interviewing can save time and expenses, by reducing travel costs and the time for meetings and interview sessions. For recruiting agencies it can save much monotony and vast quantities of time.

Our global recruiter network has been searching for a new service provider in Australia, so I figured I would give the video interview a go. I used the InterviewStream product for RolePlays and it was quite simple, fairly intuitive and while not a huge time saver for me, it saved much time for the candidates and for those I wanted to engage in my selection process. I did a more typical phone screen followed by just 3 simple questions to each of my four finalists. Their answers were recorded and it allowed me to share these recordings with two Regional Directors that would otherwise just have to go with my best judgment. It also allowed me a second benchmark to follow-up on my initial phone screen. The results were not altered by the video addition, but it did offer me greater confidence in the decisions I had made.

If you are a global recruiter, I really don’t know why you wouldn’t experiment with the use of video. Those annoying 20-minute interruptions from potential candidates on the phone could go like this…”I’m interested in your abilities. I place candidates like you in good jobs frequently and would like to learn more about what makes you unique and able to be placed with my employers. Would you mind taking 10 minutes to provide me some background on you? I will send you a link and you can respond to my video-recorded questions with the specifics appropriate to you. Since the interview allows for you to redo any answer you feel you got started incorrectly, this allows you to put your best foot forward from the start. Once I have reviewed your responses, I can tell you if you are a good fit for my practice.” Positive for you and positive for the candidate. Since candidates will need to have better skills in this area in the years ahead, you are likely helping that candidate prepare for the way the world might work.

Tell me why you wouldn’t use video or what concerns you about the use of video by recruitment agencies?

button to subscribe to NPA blog

Image courtesy of Vichaya Kiatying-Angsulee / FreeDigitalPhotos.net

 


Controlling our Clients? Surely you’re joking!

by Veronica Blatt

image of ships wheelGreg Doersching is Managing Partner and Founder of The Griffin Search Group, a national search firm working in the direct hire placement industry. He is an active recruiter who still runs a highly productive desk. He also developer and Chief Architect of the highly successful Bullseye Recruiting Process. For the past 15 years, Greg has been recognized as one of the most cutting-edge voices in the recruiting industry. Greg has spoken at several NPA conferences and is well-regarded for his candid approach and recruiter training.

I get asked by recruiters all the time, “Greg, how can I take better control over my clients?” I wish there was some kind of formula that would give you “actual” control; unfortunately that’s not reality, and I’m a strong believer in working inside the real world. So here’s the truth of the matter – the only part of the entire recruiting process that you do have control over is – yourself! This isn’t a cop-out, either. I bring this up because if you want to start having more INFLUENCE over your clients — which is something we can attain — then it starts with how you master yourself.  Here are three areas where you need to be as consistency flawless as possible if you want to earn enough respect from your clients to actually start being able to influence their decisions.

Quality Submittals – The single most important service you provide to your clients is the candidates you actually choose to present and how you choose to deliver that presentation to them. Yet so often I see recruiters sending over marginal candidates and justifying it in their own minds. Our two biggest excuses? “Well, I’ve got to send them someone so they know I’m actually working the search.” And, “I’ll send them this person and then the feedback I get will help me fine tune what I’m looking for.” Both of these justifications are the kinds of things that kill your relationships with clients because clients only see one thing: “You didn’t send me what I was looking for!!”  You want true influence? It starts with only sending candidates who are true fits for the position regardless of how long it takes you to find them!

Professional Communication – The second area where you can gain a great deal of additional influence over your client lies in how you handle communication with that client. I am a firm believer that the more professional you make you communication the more obligated your client feels to respond in a similar professional manner. To this end, I send very formal weekly update reports notifying the client on the status of the search. I send very formal interview debrief reports that detail the candidate’s thoughts on the interview. I go further in sending very detailed pre-search qualification matrix grids to my clients to force them to “sign-off” on my search parameters before I start a search.

There are lots of other tactics I employ to ensure that all my clients’ dealings leave them with the impression that they are dealing with a true professional and as such, a certain level of professional courtesy is expected on their part. I would leave you with this parting thought – do your job with a sense of P.R.I.D.E. (Personal Responsibility In Daily Excellence). If you take the focus onto yourself and work at a high level of professionalism, integrity and diligence your clients will notice. This will result in you gaining the RESPECT that you deserve and this will manifest itself in the influence you have over those clients.

Image courtesy of worradmu / FreeDigitalPhotos.net

button to subscribe to NPA blog


Build Disagreement in Your Recruitment Agency

by Dave Nerz

image of windsurfer tipping overWe all like to get along! Sometimes we do the best we can do to avoid conflict, appear supportive, and be a team player. Be careful if that is how you have built your recruitment agency. You may be insulating yourself and your business from the facts that could make you better, stronger and more able to adapt to changing conditions.

I am not suggesting that you hire argumentative consultants and employees, but you may want to offer those closest to your business the ability to voice a point of view that is unique. Most people don’t want to be different and see value in getting along, so when you find someone or some way (see ideas list below) to release the truth or expression of a contrary point of view, grab it and hang on!

The buzz word is “diversity.” Listen for it; you will hear it everywhere. In your recruitment agency it is about finding a way to release vendors, contractors, employees and partners from the convention that says they must “go along to get along.” Allowing your closest partners to express diverse points of view is a skill that should be nurtured. You should expect and encourage people to be nice when disagreeing but they should never have to apologize for holding a point of view that is not identical to your’s or the team’s. Conformity will ultimately stunt the growth and innovation in any business including a recruitment agency.

Try this:

  • Ask for all points of view on an issue before deciding.
  • Make sure everyone in a meeting expresses themselves before ending a meeting.
  • Assign the role of “devil’s advocate” to a team member.
  • Offer an anonymous “I have a different point of view” box.
  • Plan a “Do the Opposite” day where people are encouraged to push back on the status quo.
  • Reward a different or alternate point of view publicly.

Consider the costs to organizations, large and small, when dissent does not or cannot surface. Encourage your team to “rock the boat” sometimes. It beats letting them sink the ship or toppling it over!

image of explore membership button


Starting a Recruiting Agency: 6 Reasons Video Interviewing is Not Used

by Dave Nerz

image of recruiter conducting a video interviewIf you are starting a recruiting agency today, there is something new that needs to be a part of your plan: video interviewing. A recent study cited 80% of employers with more than 10,000 employees have used video interviewing to hire employees or screen candidates. Even small employers are now using video and agency recruiters best be aware of this trend. In the future, employers may ask for video resumes or expect a video screen be done on each candidate. Face-to-face is great, but the time and cost associated with face-to-face is astronomical when compared to the speed and low cost of video.

Here are some excuses I have heard used for not using or considering video as a part of the strategy when starting a recruiting agency:

  1. Not Aware – Some firms just did not consider video as they planned their agency because they were unaware of the trend and the technology.
  2. Don’t See Value – Many agency recruiters don’t see value and believe face-to-face or phone is better to enough.
  3. Concern About Legal Implications – Some starting a recruiting agency are concerned about the eventual legal implications of video interviewing.
  4. Cost – Some agency recruiting firms are of the opinion that video interviewing is expensive.
  5. Unwilling to Change Process – Many have never used video and are unwilling to make a change in process.
  6. Unaware of Savings/Success – The time and cost savings, the speed to screen, and the quality of hire can all improve but many starting a recruiting agency are not yet tuned into the potential.

These are good reasons, but now that you have read about the trends, the savings, the potential effectiveness there really is no good excuse. It is pretty simple and low cost to try. NPA has a partnership with InterviewStream but there are many good providers and even some low-cost options that connect with Skype or iPhone.

Let me know if you have clients using video or refusing to use video. I see this as a game-changer for agency recruiters because you can do a basic phone screen in way less time and it can be shared with your client when necessary. Maybe you see it differently?

Split Fee Placement Agreement

 

Image courtesy of Vichaya Kiatying-Angsulee / FreeDigitalPhotos.net


5 Crazy Mobile Recruiting Stats You Should Know

by Veronica Blatt

image of mobile recruiting on a tabletMobile recruiting continues to dominate conversations about hiring and job search. If your recruiting firm is still behind the curve, here are 5 crazy mobile recruiting statistics that should give you a kick in the pants:

1. Indeed has the #1 free business app for iOS and Android. Are you using Indeed as part of your mobile recruiting strategy? If not, do you have a mobile app of your own? Or a responsively-designed website? Read the rest of this entry »


5 Things Independent Recruiters Can Learn from Successful Business and Sales People

by Veronica Blatt

image of wooden blocks spelling learnToday’s guest blogger is Julie Parsons of Premium Consulting in Brisbane, Queensland, Australia. Julie is a member of the NPA board of directors. Premium Consulting is a boutique independent recruiting firm that provides professional and practical recruitment consulting advice specializing in retained recruitment, partial services, psychometric assessment and appraisals, outplacement and career counseling.

Independent recruiters can learn a lot from following these 5 traits of successful business and sales people:

1. They See Opportunity Where Others Don’t
Successful business and sales people are open-minded and enthusiastic. They find opportunities where others fail to see them. They ask questions, investigate problems and solicit feedback in order to find solutions to problems. When and if a problem occurs, they see it as an opportunity to learn more about the issues to be solved. They speak to customers, clients, mentors and experts to actively seek out solutions. They don’t see their lack of a particular skill set as a hindrance, rather as an opportunity to learn from others, or as a chance to go out and get help from those who are skilled in that specific area. Rather than see their business fail, they outsource a task, re-educate themselves or bring in professional help and networks to help them to succeed. Independent recruiters can use capitalize on this technique to build strategic partnerships with their clients.

2. They Add Value
A successful business person can see beyond the immediate goal of simply building their business or career. They see value in giving back to others, in working to ensure their business success is not at the expense of others, because in so doing, they continue to grow and prosper. Some simple but effective examples for independent recruiters include:
•    Being available for value-add free advice
•    Establishing ongoing customer communication such as an e-newsletter, Facebook page or blog that provides valuable and useful information for clients and the community (at no cost)
•    Linking valued customers with preferred providers of useful services or information
•    Establishing and delivering valuable information seminars for clients.

3. They Are Proactive
Successful business people don’t stop at learning about a new field, they are proactive. They take steps to get things done and they do them. They implement new ideas, solutions or systems quickly, regardless of their fear of failure. They realise that in order to progress, they need to take some risks and make things happen. This doesn’t mean they just leap into the dark with the first new idea that pops into their head. Before kicking off a new idea, solution or strategy, they identify what they want the outcome to be, e.g. generate more leads, start a new business niche or create a bigger or more loyal client base. With this in mind, independent recruiters can research solutions, talk to experts, and seek advice in order to actually implement new ideas.

4. They Build a Support Network
Successful business people realise they can’t do it all on their own. They recognise their own limitations and value the different skills, expertise and experience of others. By building a support network of mentors, advisers, experts, specialists, colleagues and friends, they have access to a combination of valuable resources, skills, experiences and talents that are beyond their own abilities. The successful business or sales person sees how their limitations can put a business opportunity at risk, and as such they call on their support network for assistance – whether that is asking a colleague to take on a job, outsourcing a particular process or employing a new staff member. As independent recruiters, how strong is your support network?

5. They Understand Their Clients
A successful business person ensures they understand their target market before trying to influence or sell a new product or service to them. They take steps to understand the needs and wants of their customer and that industry. They learn about what will influence the prospect or customer, what they really want, and then look for ways to deliver on these desires. However, the successful business person also understands this is not done by data collection alone. They understand that trust is all-important to the target market. They understand that if the client cannot trust the influencer (i.e. the business), the client is likely to have doubts and ultimately reject the connection. Successful business people take steps to positively connect with, and support their target market through regular and ongoing communication (e-newsletters, Facebook posts, blogs, emails, personal visits and phone calls) and consistently high levels of customer service. By doing this, a Trusted Advisor relationship is developed. Independent recruiters would do well to strive for that same type of relationship with their clients.

What other things can independent recruiters learn from the business and sales arenas?

7-trends


Headhunter Network Shares 7 Reasons for Slow Hiring Clients

by Dave Nerz

image of turtle representing slow clientsWhen you run a headhunter network, as I do, you hear many good and bad stories about agency recruiting. Lately I have heard that recruiters are growing weary of how slow employers are to act on good candidates. I have been doing an informal survey of what drives this lack of urgency for clients resulting in slow and ineffective hiring decisions.

 

  1. Unclear Job Descriptions. Sometime the speed to hire is slowed by a lack of job clarity. In our headhunter network, I hear about jobs that start off with one set of expectations and by the time the hire is made, the role has changed as have the salary and the expectations.
  2. Change of Management. Agency recruiters have reported slowed decision-making when ownership and managers change. No one wants to make a hire when the company is in flux.
  3. Complex Interview Process. When the list of employer interviews changes and grows, you can be sure the hiring process will be delayed. Those in our headhunter network indicate the fastest decisions are made when the interview process is defined in advance and is maintained through the hiring process. Scheduling third and fourth interviews is one way to make sure top talent is chased away.
  4. Cost of Open Positions Not Understood. Open positions have a cost. Unfilled openings burden the people that must pick up the overflow of work. For positions that are truly valuable, the revenue lost is measured in most companies as 3 to 5 times the annual salary…real revenue that is being lost. If more companies realized this, they would be focused on adding speed to their process. Many times managers that are not “profit centers” but are “cost centers” view open positions as “cost savings.”
  5. Slow is Better Mentality. It is not uncommon for employers to believe that slowing down the process will help them make a better hiring decision.  There is logic in this belief but members of NPA’s headhunter network agree that it only holds true for the disorganized client that does not have a clear position description, a solid management team, and a proven interview process. For the majority of employers, slow decisions assure that the highest quality candidates will be gone before the decision to hire is executed.
  6. No Sense of Urgency. This is usually an extension of the leadership and perhaps a few of the other items listed above. Unless someone is holding the hiring manager accountable for a timely hire, the hire will be a lower priority than other responsibilities. When employers engage agency recruiting firms, firms can act to hold a hiring manager accountable — but only if supported at the leadership level of the organization.
  7. Failure to Understand Market Conditions. This one is a constant source of conflict between agency recruiters and employers. The agencies understand the shifts in market dynamics and employers tend to be informed by external news media reporting. So the employer hears that unemployment is at near record highs and assumes this means they have the pick of talent just waiting for an offer. They do not understand that for university graduates with 5 to 10 years of experience, unemployment is at nearly full employment levels. That means that anyone really wanting a job has one. Employers can mistakenly believe they are in a job-driven market when the shift to a candidate-driven market occurred in months or years prior.

In summary, slow response time is costing employers money and causing them to lose the best available talent. Competitors are hiring the top candidates while other employers are leaving positions unfilled. Moving too slowly to extend offers to qualified candidates is sacrificing a competitive advantage. Scheduling that 3rd or 4th interview may cost an employer the best talent. Sometimes employers need to learn the hard way. Agency recruiting firms can act to inform employers, but employers need to adopt a “get it done now” sense of urgency in order to compete for top talent in today’s market.

7-trends


Three Important Considerations When Starting a Recruitment Agency

by Veronica Blatt

image of starting lanes on a running trackIf you’ve been thinking of starting a recruitment agency of your own, you’re probably already aware of the importance of developing both a good business plan and a good marketing plan. Here are three other important considerations:

1. Have enough money. Conventional wisdom states that you will need to have enough cash reserves to support your new business for 18 months with no revenue. Historically, half of new business start-ups fail within the first five years, and a significant portion of those failures are due to being undercapitalized. Before starting a recruitment agency, figure out where the money will come from – personal savings, loans from family or a business partner, conventional financing, etc. Trim your personal overhead as much as possible so that you can still pay your household bills on a greatly reduced – or nonexistent – income.

2. Have a plan to run a business, not just a desk. If you’ve been a successful recruiter working for someone else, it’s easy to think that starting a recruitment agency of your own will increase your personal income. That’s not necessarily true. When you’re working for someone else, you’re responsible for your personal production. You may have help in the form of administrative or research support, or even business development, which allows you to spend your time on what you are good at — making placements. When you go out on your own, your budget may not allow for administrative or research support. You’ll be responsible for business development (which does not include the clients and candidates belonging to your former employer, right?). And you’ll have to do all the other things that come with running a business like bookkeeping, paying taxes, and dealing with service providers (website developer, telephone provider, ISPs, etc.). All of those things leave less time for making placements, which probably means less money.

3. Decide if you want to go it alone, purchase a franchise, or join a recruiting network. Starting a recruitment agency is a risky venture, just like any other start-up. There are different business models to consider, which can impact the risk:

  • Go it alone. Use your own knowledge and a “bare-bones” style such as a laptop and Skype from your home when starting a recruitment agency. This option allows you to be completely entrepreneurial and requires the least amount of upfront cash. It’s also the riskiest option, because you won’t have any support to keep your fledgling business moving. What if it takes 6 months to land your first client? A year to make a placement? Can you survive that long?
  • Purchase a franchise. A recruiting franchise provides you with infrastructure for your business, training, possibly software, advertising, market penetration, and other support. However, there is a very high cost of entry — anywhere from US $25,000 to US $200,000 — and you’ll be paying franchise fees (typically 5% – 9% of your gross revenue) every month. It can be difficult and expensive to leave the franchise if it’s not working out for you. It can also limit your autonomy as a business owner. If you like a corporate model with lots of training, a franchise can be a great option.
  • Join a recruiting network. There are formal and informal networks, free and paid. A recruiting network provides you access to candidates, jobs, trading partners, and peer support. All of these can make starting a recruitment agency a little easier. You can provide candidates for your trading partners’ jobs, or rely on partners to source candidates for your jobs. And it’s invaluable to be able to call up another recruitment agency owner for advice. Your partners will lift you up when you struggle and celebrate your successes.

Starting a recruitment agency is an exciting prospect with a high income potential. Do your homework, develop a great plan, and look for options that provide affordable support to increase your odds of success!

image of button for free checklist to evaluate split placement networks


Independent Recruiters, Do Your Clients Insist Industry Experience is Required?

by Veronica Blatt

Today’s post is from Russ Bray with Southern Recruiting Solutions in Tampa, Florida. Russ is a two-time member of the NPA Board of Directors, as well as a long-time member of the network. Southern Recruiting Solutions specializes in placing professionals in the chemical, oil/gas, and manufacturing industries throughout the U.S.

image of newspaper career sectionAs independent recruiters, how often do we hear from clients that industry experience is REQUIRED? A lot! Because of that I wanted to share with you a little detail about a split placement I just did. A trading partner placed a candidate of mine into a maintenance manager position with a chemical industry client of hers. What was interesting is my candidate had no prior chemical industry experience! She also told me she placed someone from the aerospace industry into chemical.

The candidate and I had talked about this during my initial phone screen. He had done some job searching on his own, talked to some other independent recruiters, and knew the scenario. Chemical and oil/gas companies would not consider his background because he worked in the steel industry. (Note: I’m not picking on the chemical industry. It just so happens that’s the area I’m working in currently. In my previous experience recruiting in information technology and aerospace/defense, I heard the same thing.)

Everything else about him looked good in my opinion. Good tenure, degree, reasonable salary, professional to work with and we both felt a lot of the equipment in the steel plant was similar to what is used in a chemical facility.

Well, kudos to my trading partner for giving him a shot. Her client saw the value in the candidate as well.

What makes this a more critical problem today? Earlier this year, NPA members listened to an industry speaker quote some Department of Labor statistics about the talent shortage. Some of you will also know what I am talking about. From now until about 2020 we are facing a shortage of professional personnel in the 6-20 million ranges. Share that with your clients next time you speak with them. Also let them know that other companies are making some concessions for this very reason. It’s a variation on the saying, “Don’t let perfect get in the way of good.” Lou Adler would say this is what is wrong with skills- and experience-based job descriptions, which focus on what a candidate HAS instead of what a candidate can DO. By helping clients define success based on performance instead of on skills and experience, independent recruiters might find a lot more opportunities for great candidates who come from similar – but not exact – industries.

Obviously there are jobs where industry experience is mandatory and you’re not going to change their mind. But in addition to listening to your client (regardless of the industries you work) remember that as independent recruiters your job is also to advise your client on whether their expectations are realistic. If the job has been open for six months, obviously there is a problem.  A good question to ask when taking the job order is, “If I can show you a candidate that meets the vast majority of your requirements but comes from a different industry would you like to see him/her? This could allow you (the employer) to fill this position much quicker and stop the job vacancy from costing your company money.”

What is your experience with clients hiring candidates from a different industry? What do you hear from other independent recruiters? Comment below!

image of button for free checklist to evaluate split placement networks

 

 


Please ensure Javascript is enabled for purposes of website accessibility